When a three year old is in tantrum mode, the laws of reason and logic don’t apply.
SuburbanDaddy: When you calm down, you can have it back.
It doesn’t matter what “it” is. Could be a toy, pillow, or piece of dirt.
Thing 2: Stop talking. Stop taaalkiiing [whining]
SuburbanDaddy: I can talk if I want. Why don’t you go to the family room?
Thing 2: But then I can’t hear you.
SuburbanDaddy: I thought that’s what you wanted?
[Begin 10 minute meltdown]